Showing posts with label Constitutional Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Constitutional Court. Show all posts

Friday, 30 December 2016

An Overview Of Zambia's Political Scene In 2016

President Lungu unveils the amended constitution
By Paul Shalala


2016 was a year which started with landmark decisions which would shape the future of this country.

On January 5th, President Edgar Lungu assented to the amendments of the republican constitution, bringing on board several changes which the Zambian public had yearned for years.

These are clauses and articles which the public had consistently submitted to successive constitution review commissions.

Some had described President LUNGU’s decision to allow the amendments as a matter of life and death especially with the 50 percent plus one presidential winning threshold.

This threshold replaced the decades old first past the post which was very controversial, allowing minority presidents to win even with the slimmest of margins.

"The 50+1% threshold worked very well this year. It helped the people of Zambia choose a popular president," said William Nyirenda, S.C. a prominent Kitwe lawyer in an interview.

Further, the 1996 amendment which brought the requirement for presidential candidates to have both parents born in Zambia was scrapped off.

This brought to an end the infamous parentage clause which barred most politicians to run for the highest office in the land.

Among the most popular clauses in the amended constitution was the Vice President running mate clause.

This clause forced political parties to have a presidential candidate and their running mates during the run up to the August 11 general elections.

Secondly, it is in 2016 when Zambia adopted a definite date for general elections: the second Thursday of August every after five years.

This put to rest the old practice of sitting presidents choosing the election date.

This usually did not go well with the opposition because sometimes it would play well to the incumbent if they chose a closer date.
Zambians voting during the general elections on August 11

Another significant addition to the constitution was the adoption of dual citizenship which had been championed by Zambians in the diaspora.

Since then, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs has even come up with the diaspora policy which is expected to help Zambians abroad in taking party in the development of the motherland.

According to the constitution, all matters of citizenship are to be administered by the Citizenship Board which is yet to be established.

On the local government scene, the amendments gave universal suffrage to the election of Mayors and Council Chairpersons.

For the first time since the return of multi-party politics 25 years ago, Zambian voters elected their heads of city, municipal and district councils as opposed to the old systems were councilors would vote for their city fathers.

However, this amendment brought about a huge debate whether the Mayors and Council Chairpersons had executive powers or not.

"We can not have two chief executive officers at the local authority: the Mayor and the Town Clerk. The Mayor is not executive as claimed by many, the constitution is clear that the Town Clerk will continue being chief executive while the Mayor is the political head of the policy formulation process," said Alderman Patrick Tembo, a long serving Councillor in Kitwe and former Vice President of the Local Government Association of Zambia.

A number of young Mayors and Council Chairpersons were elected across the country.

The youngest are Kitwe Mayor Christopher Kangombe, Luanshya Mayor Nathan Chanda and Kabwe Mayor Prince Chileshe who were all elected at the age of 31 in August.

In legal affairs, this year’s constitutional changes created the Constitutional Court and the Court of Appeal.
Kitwe Mayor Christopher Kangombe and his wife

The constitutional court did not even have chance to settle down as it was quickly involved in resolving disputes arising from the August 11 general elections.

Despite its ruling over the opposition’s appeal of the re-election of President Lungu, the cases are still being heard in the lower courts.

In terms of the general elections held in August, the ruling Patriotic Front secured another five year term after a tightly contested polls.

The party also increased its number of MPs to 83 while the opposition UPND came out second but increased its numbers in Parliament to 58.

Other parties with MPs in the house are MMD (4) and FDD (1).

Interestingly, the adoption process both for the PF and UPND was marred with protests and surprising decisions which forced most preferred candidates to contest as independents.

Both the PF and the UPND did not release their list of adopted parliamentary candidates before the nomination date.

In some instances, two candidates from a single political party showed up at nomination centers with nomination papers and it had to take dialogue and phone calls for only one candidate to file in on that respective party ticket.

According to some observers, this situation led the country to have an unprecedented number of 14 independent Members of Parliament.

Keembe MP Princess Kasune Zulu
This was a huge rise from three independent MPs who had been elected countrywide after the 2011 general elections.

In terms of gender representation, the men continue to dominate though the number of female MPs has risen from 22 in the 2011 to 2016 term to 30 female MPs after this year's elections.

Among those elected female MPs is Princess Kasune Zulu, Zambia's first lawmaker to openly declare that she is living with HIV.

She is the UPND's MP in Keembe Constituency.

The elections also saw a number of MPs who had lost their seats in 2011 returning to parliament after a five year absence.

Notable among them are Mubika Mubika (Shang'ombo), Douglas Syakalima (Siavonga) and Peter Daka (Msanzala).

However, one of the huge setbacks of the nation was the collapse of the referendum which was held alongside the general elections.

Very few Zambians voted in the referendum, failing to reach the 50% threshold to validate the process.

"It is very disappointing that the campaign for social and economic rights in the Bill of Rights was politicized. People were told that the Bill of Rights had gay rights and they shunned it. We lost a big opportunity," said Gerald Mutelo, the President of Democratic Governance and Human Rights Advocates on a live TV programme on TV1 recently.

Indeed, 2016 was a watershed moment in the political field in Zambia.

It is the year when many of those contentious clauses and articles were enacted into law, making the governance system more user friendly.

However, 2017 may not be as interesting as 2016.

But we wait and see how the political scene will unfold.

Like they say, in politics there is no dull moment.

Monday, 8 December 2014

Mozambican Democracy: A Possible Model For Zambia

Campaign posters on a street in Mozambique
By Paul Shalala in Maputo, Mozambique

Mozambique may have emerged from two decades of war, but its way ahead in its path of strengthening its democratic institutions.

This southern African country gained its independence from Portugal in 1975 but it soon descended into a brutal war which only came to an end in 1992.

Since then, Mozambique has held democratic elections at local government and parliamentary level as well as electing three Presidents so far.

My one week stay in the Mozambican districts of Bilene, Manhica and Maputo in late November showed me how democracy is flourishing in this emerging gas producer.

Election officials in Mozambique
All across the 200 kilometers stretch of the Maputo-Bilene road are posters of major political parties that took part in the 15 October, 2014 General Elections where ruling party candidate Felipe Nyusi emerged victorious as the country's new President.

Zambia may have had many years of multi-party politics but its still lagging behind in a number of ways that Mozambiaque has become a shining example.

Below are some of the progressive democratic institutions and laws that Zambia is still trying to establish which Mozambique has already institutionalised:

1. Constitutional Court:

In the Final Draft Constitution released by the Zambian government on 24 October, 2014, a Constitutional Court has been proposed to determine many constitutional issues.
Supporters of opposition candidate Daviz Simango

One of these issues is the determination of elections and the overall winner of presidential elections.

This court also hears and determines all electoral petitions and disputes.

Mozambique already has a constitutional court and according to that country's constitution, this court has a 45 day period from the day the Mozambican Electoral Commission announces the election results to the day it is supposed to officially announce the winner.

2. Transition Period

In Zambia, a winning Presidential candidate is supposed to be sworn in within 24 hours after being declared victorious.

Many observers say 24 hours is too short a time for swearing in a president due to the many irregularities and petitions that may arise after the election.

But in Mozambique, their constitution has a 45 day transition period from the day the Electoral Commission announces the result to the day the new president is sworn in.
Renamo Presidential candidate Afonso Dhlakama

This period helps the out-going government to hand over to the new government and it allows the new team to be oriented into the affairs of the nation.

Currently, the ruling party FRELIMO's Filipe Nyusi is within the 45 day period where he is waiting for the Mozambican Constitutional Court to declare him winner following the declaration of his 15 October victory by the Electoral Commission.

During this time, Nyusi is being taken through the day to day running of the country and he is also constituting his own Cabinet which he will only announce after he is sworn in.

A local journalist jokingly told me that during this time, ruling party officials keep their phones on in case Nyusi phones them for a place in his government and others are busy issuing statements on TV so that Nyusi can notice their "hardwork."

A campaign poster for FRELIMO candidate Felipe Nyusi
3. Freedom of Information Law

In the last week of November 2014, the Mozambican parliament passed the Freedom of Information Law which has been hailed by several stakeholders as progressive.

This law was pushed by civil society and media bodies in the country.

In Zambia, the Access to Information Bill has been shelved for 14 years following its withdrawal from parliament in 2002.

Activists and media organisations argue that once Zambia enacts this bill into law, the public will have power to question the authorities on issues they need clarity.

They argue that in the absence of such a law, transparency and accountability are hard to be ascertained.